RCSCALEBUILDER.COM - Cutting Parts For Plans

Home>Forums>Site Polls>Cutting Parts For Plans

Post Reply New Topic

Forum Jump

3 Pages 1 2 3

Poll Question : Which do you prefer when building from plans
Poll Choice	Votes	Poll Statistics
Purchase a full wood kit from a kit cutter	191	[ 42.35% ]
Purchase a "short" wood kit from a kit cutter	108	[ 23.95% ]
Prefer to cut your own	152	[ 33.70% ]
You can not vote in this poll

Author / Post

	Lars.Baeter Site Supporter	Joined: March/18/2004 Germany Posts: 421 IP Logged
Posted: March/23/2006 at 9:21am		Quote

Sometimes I'm asking myself how I could have built modelairplanes without all these PC Stuff, without asking thousands of people in different forums for support, without 'googling' around for special parts and detailed images and without all my expensive tools I have ??? ??? ???

Parts of an laser cut kit are really noble and I admire them but often the wood quality of a full wood kit not. Sometimes the wood is warped and to heavy or to soft. So I prefer to order the wood from my special local dealer who delivers manual sorted 1A quality just in the weight I want it.

Depending the laser cut parts. Cutting all these formers and ribs by myself is pure joy. I love this work and I could do it all the time. O.K. my parts haven't always the same quality of laser cut parts and when the part in the plan has the wrong shape my selfmade part become also the wrong shape, (so there is finally no difference to a laser cut short kit )

I enjoy most of the building phase and have no pressure at all to become faster ;) but if I could I would mill parts by myself. My models become all electric powered and often I have to modify something. It would be a pleasure to modify parts from the plans with a CAD Software and to mill then by myself but I would never complete pass on sawing parts by msyself.

Cheers!, LarS 8^)

__________________
"In theory, theory and practice are the same, in practice they are not"

	Darren40 Basic Member	Joined: September/11/2003 Canada Posts: 95 IP Logged
Posted: March/23/2006 at 9:17pm		Quote

I voted for a full wood kit, but only because I prefer it all else being equal. If the kit cutter uses good quality wood and the parts all fit well, then there's no point in spending hours cutting from patterns. I wouldn't mind and might even prefer building from a short kit (excluding foam wings) except that the nearest LHS is several hundred miles away so its a hassle for me to get quality balsa, especially since I want to hand pick. I've been building a Skyshark kit and everything fits together very well and the wood quality is very good with very few minor exceptions. I would say the same for an Airsail kit I built earlier. Because of my location, a full kit is most practical for me from either of these manufacturers. I've built several red box TF kits years ago and they weren't bad. However, I recently acquired a TF Gold Edition kit and the wood is very heavy. It's the worst wood I've seen in any kit, by far. I bought the kit on Ebay with the horiz. stab. already built. The builder did a fine job, but the wood is so heavy I'll have to build from scratch to replace it. I'll probably replace 80% of the parts in the kit to bring the weight down to where it should be for a bird this size. (Now I understand why everyone says the TF kits build heavy and need more power than specified. Based on the contents of this kit I probably wouldn't buy another TF kit unless it was a short kit. So, in my case my preference has a lot to do with my location and the quality of wood in the kit.

__________________
Dryden, ON Canada

in progress:

Sig PT-19 converting to PT-26
scratch built 1/6 I-16 Ishak

	Mode 1 Basic Member	Joined: February/13/2007 United States Posts: 89 IP Logged
Posted: February/17/2007 at 8:23am		Quote

I voted cut my own, however, I have never used a cutter so have no experience. I'll be building a 1/5th scale CT Davies Sopwith Pup from plans and hope to use a cutter to cut out all them wing ribs and half ribs!

	ERFR Site Supporter	Joined: October/25/2005 Israel Posts: 637 IP Logged
Posted: February/17/2007 at 9:33am		Quote

Prefer to cut my own.

One "practical" reason - by the time a custom kit would get shipped to my corner of the world, the cost would be enormous.

One "personal" reason - it allows changing materials and laminating the thicker parts for a better structure in my opinon.

__________________
Erez

	Connieman Basic Member	Joined: March/28/2007 Canada Posts: 60 IP Logged
Posted: May/11/2007 at 5:26am		Quote

Like another modeler said, this is question of personal preference really, there is not one or two answers for it in reality, everybody like to go around this as they feel comfortable. For me i like to cut my own parts from the plans, mind you i have never bought a kit from laser kit cutters out there yet but i am sure if there are errors on the drawings from which the kit is being cut from, you will find them on the parts and their fitting also, i highly doubt if any of kit cutters would take there sweet time to rectify errors in plans and then cut the kit.
Plus when i am doing my own cutting i can see how the model was designed and if there are errors on the plans, i could fix them as i go.

__________________
Current build on the table: Super Connie L1049G http://www.rcscalebuilder.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=8201 &PN=1
Kits will commence soon. Check it out.

	Red_Jeepster Basic Member	Joined: March/27/2009 United States Posts: 4 IP Logged
Posted: May/12/2009 at 9:13pm		Quote

I voted for my own cutting. Really, the time I spend selecting wood, positioning the piece for grain direction, cutting out the parts, etc is PART of building IMHO.

What is the hurry? To build a masterpiece one doesn't mind being part of the whole process.

I am not against kit cutters at all. I have never used one, so I don't have any business talking about them, good or bad. Would I use one? Sure if I was building for someone else and they wanted to pay for the service.

__________________
AMA #208619

	Hopper5775 Lifetime Site Supporter	Joined: June/17/2008 United States Posts: 640 IP Logged
Posted: July/04/2009 at 8:36am		Quote

Well, as I am drawing close to the the end of my first scratch build, I'd have to say cutting my own. Now, I enjoy building from a kit too, as there is always something to fix and to fabricated that isn't included in the kit. But as I wind down this project and get ready to have others see it, I find a definite sense of pride building in me knowing I'll be able to say, "Yeah, I cut and glued every stick in her." It's been a long and sometimes tedious process, but I have enjoyed it so much.

__________________
Claude "Hopper" Christ
Tulsa Glue Dobbers
Tulsa,OK

Flying: 1/4 BUSA Cub, 1/4 BUSA Nieuport 11
On Hold: 1/4 SS DIII, 1/4 Sopwith Baby
Building: 1/3 BUSA DVII for a club member

	john62544 Basic Member	Joined: November/19/2008 United States Posts: 878 IP Logged
Posted: July/12/2009 at 5:46pm		Quote

My vote for purchasing a full wood kit from a kit cutter is of course depending on the quality of the company doing the kit cutting.

John,TX

Forum Jump

3 Pages 1 2 3

Post Reply New Topic

Similar topics you might be interested in...

Cutting Kit From Plans

Cutting a Kit for a Ryan STA

Cutting foam cores.

cutting up plans

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot create polls in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum

Portal Home Forum Icon

Forum Home Forum Icon

Your Privacy