RCSCALEBUILDER.COM - Yellow P-47 Razorback

Home>Forums>Show Your Stuff!!!>Yellow P-47 Razorback

Search Within This Topic

Post Reply New Topic

Forum Jump

4 Pages 1 2 3 4

Author / Post

	Flyin'Tim Basic Member	Joined: 2019/June/05 United States Posts: 76 IP Logged
Posted: 2021/September/06 at 1:46pm		Quote

I didn't start a build thread on this plane because it was too far along when I joined here. Been a long build. Started it, moved to something else, got back to it and so on for several years. Now it is almost complete, cockpit kit, half gear doors and some other details left. It will be clear coated shortly but I wouldn't mind a little feedback on panel lines rivets and weathering before I do. Thanks for looking and for any feedback.

__________________
Primarily Scale Warbirds and Bipes:
33% Stearman, 33% Pitts Challenger, 33% Der Jager, 1/5 P-51, 1/6 P-47 x 2, 1/6 AT-6. Ziroli Hellcat, 1/6 Rare Bear ........and many more

	Peter Site Supporter	Joined: 2005/January/20 Australia Posts: 640 IP Logged
Posted: 2021/September/06 at 4:48pm		Quote

Nice work!

Peter

__________________
Building:
Yellow Acft A4 EDF
Chilton DW1A
Flying:
Comper Streak
Repairing:
Pilot 1/4 scale Tiger Moth
Mig-15

	Flyin'Tim Basic Member	Joined: 2019/June/05 United States Posts: 76 IP Logged
Posted: 2021/September/06 at 5:18pm		Quote

Thanks Peter,

I'm starting to get some feedback that more dirtiness and weathering is appropriate for this bird since it is a replica of the actual fighter. Any thoughts?

Thanks,

Tim

__________________
Primarily Scale Warbirds and Bipes:
33% Stearman, 33% Pitts Challenger, 33% Der Jager, 1/5 P-51, 1/6 P-47 x 2, 1/6 AT-6. Ziroli Hellcat, 1/6 Rare Bear ........and many more

	Sparky Lifetime Site Supporter Head Curmudgeon	Joined: 2004/February/10 United States Posts: 8140 IP Logged
Posted: 2021/September/06 at 7:34pm		Quote

Does it look like the doc's?
That's the real test.
If you don't have docs do what you think is right..... Its easy to overdo the weathering

Sparky

__________________
Sparky
Brown County, Indiana
VK Sopwith Camel (E)
TopRC FW-190, Zenoah GT-80
Bates F6F Hellcat, Saito FG60-R3
Gamma RIP

	BobH Site Supporter	Joined: 2003/October/24 United States Posts: 5894 IP Logged
Posted: 2021/September/06 at 7:59pm		Quote

Subtle is better in my opinion. These planes had ground crews to look after them. Normally they were relatively cleaned and cared for.

	Flyin'Tim Basic Member	Joined: 2019/June/05 United States Posts: 76 IP Logged
Posted: 2021/September/06 at 8:32pm		Quote

Thanks Fellas, all the input really helps. Docs on this original plane are all black and white and very grainy. I can copy all of the panel lines, rivets, colors, nomenclature and graphics pretty well but the actual plane is hard to replicate from the old photos. I don't want to use other models as a reference because they did what I am doing.....guessing. I am going to "dirty" it up a bit....it looks too clean to be in theatre. I was a crewcheif in the Army on helicopters and the working birds never looked "show" quality as I think my model kinda looks. Needs to look more like a working machine. I'll post some more pics after a bit more work before clear coat and get some more comments.......I invite all the criticism I can get, all it does is help IMO.

Thanks again,

Tim

__________________
Primarily Scale Warbirds and Bipes:
33% Stearman, 33% Pitts Challenger, 33% Der Jager, 1/5 P-51, 1/6 P-47 x 2, 1/6 AT-6. Ziroli Hellcat, 1/6 Rare Bear ........and many more

	Sparky Lifetime Site Supporter Head Curmudgeon	Joined: 2004/February/10 United States Posts: 8140 IP Logged
Posted: 2021/September/07 at 8:05am		Quote

Look around RCSB there is a CARF P-47 that looks pretty good.
Pictures aren't always the best thing to judge your airplane and in the end make it the way you want. If I were to say anything here are my comments based on the pictures you have posted and no reference to your documents.
Gun area too dirty, Panels/rivet line mid fuse too obvious, tail too clean and rivet lines too obvious.
If you are going to compete in scale contest match the doc's!

Sparky

__________________
Sparky
Brown County, Indiana
VK Sopwith Camel (E)
TopRC FW-190, Zenoah GT-80
Bates F6F Hellcat, Saito FG60-R3
Gamma RIP

	Flyin'Tim Basic Member	Joined: 2019/June/05 United States Posts: 76 IP Logged
Posted: 2021/October/31 at 9:33pm		Quote

Just a few more details and cockpit to finish......I got the rivets panel lines and weathering as good as I can do with the technique I used. Clear coat is satin finish but I think a flat finish may have been better. I'll post final pics and maiden flight pics in a few weeks. Thanks for all the feedback Fellas.

Tim

__________________
Primarily Scale Warbirds and Bipes:
33% Stearman, 33% Pitts Challenger, 33% Der Jager, 1/5 P-51, 1/6 P-47 x 2, 1/6 AT-6. Ziroli Hellcat, 1/6 Rare Bear ........and many more

Forum Jump

4 Pages 1 2 3 4

Post Reply New Topic

Similar topics you might be interested in...

P-47 Razorback

GS P-47 Razorback

JDM P-47 Razorback

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot create polls in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum

Portal Home Forum Icon

Forum Home Forum Icon

Your Privacy